pH7

06. The Cinderella Service
The government is simply failing to deliver on its mental health promises, says Oliver Heald MP, and sufferers remain forgotten
The government is simply failing to deliver on its mental health promises, says Oliver Heald MP, and sufferers remain forgotten

The government promised to cut deaths from suicide by 20 per cent within 10 years, yet three years later it has still not produced a strategy and is missing its target. Meanwhile deaths from suicide are up by one per cent.

The decision of nice on modern atypical drugs for mental health sufferers is an important one. It is wrong if an individual is not given the choice of medicines with fewer side effects, particularly where the medicine is given compulsorily. It is a disgrace that the decision has taken so long. Why should one of the most innovative countries in Europe be one of the slowest to allow patients to receive new treatments?

The use of modern medicines is not the only issue facing mental health sufferers. Users, carers and staff all tell me of their concerns that the government is simply failing to deliver on its mental health promises.

There was an initial welcome for its plans, but this has turned to disillusion because so little change has been seen on the ground. We were told that mental health was to be a priority, but for users, carers and staff it does not feel like it. After promising a great deal, the government seems to have forgotten about mental health sufferers. The government promised to cut deaths from suicide by 20 per cent within 10 years, yet three years later it has still not produced a strategy and is missing its target. Meanwhile deaths from suicide are up by one per cent.

In 1999 the government also promised a much-needed new Mental Health Bill but, again, three years later we find ourselves without one - letting down all those people who need our help. This is all the more surprising, as everyone agrees that the system for assessment and sectioning needs reform (although not about the detail of the government's proposals) - yet still, no bill.

The government is now halfway through the time it set itself to achieve its targets in the Mental Health National Service Framework, but the latest figures show that it is falling far short. A crisis for somebody suffering from mental illness can be a matter of life and death. The government promised 335 crisis resolution teams, but so far only 52 have been established. Only four per cent of local teams have complete services in place.

For young people there is no indication as to when the mental health module of the Children's National Service Framework is to be ready. Only 16 of the promised 50 early intervention teams have been established.

Additionally the Audit Commission has recently expressed its concern that specialist teams for older people with mental health problems were only fully available in less than half of all areas - and less than half of GPs had received sufficient training to help them diagnose and manage dementia.

Carers are the main support for those with mental illness, yet the government's promise of 700 extra staff to enable carers to have much needed breaks, has so far led to not one single extra person being employed. There were also to be 1,000 new graduate primary care workers but the government does not even have a system to monitor the target.

Apart from the concerns about delivery of targets, there is increasing evidence that money for mental health is not reaching those who need it, leaving government promises unrealised. The way in which a nation treats its mentally ill is a mark of how civilised and humane the society is. Sadly the outlook in this country is bleak. The government cannot afford just to talk about mental health - it must actually do something.

A written Parliamentary Answer from the Minister, Jacqui Smith MP, has shown that none of the funds earmarked for health authorities are protected or ringfenced, and that £15 million allocated for mental health is being held centrally with no indication of how it will be spent.

This news comes on top of evidence late last year that mental health services for children did not receive £10 million allocated to it. The message that I hear from those on the ground is that the money just does not reach the front line. It is all too easy, given the lack of ringfencing, for money to be moved from mental health into other more "popular" areas.

This state of affairs cannot be allowed to continue - particularly in the field of children's mental health. The film A Beautiful Mind demonstrates just why it is such an important area for investment. Ignoring it is short-sighted and means more expenditure further down the line.

Finally, the issue of choice is one which MIND is currently highlighting in its "My Choice" campaign. When I attended the launch at The King's Fund, I was very impressed by the evidence that modern medicines and other treatments taken together, can lead to significant improvements for patients. But unless the funding reaches the front line there will not be genuine choice for patients. So the long-delayed decision of NICE on the use of modern atypical medicines is very important - but so are the issues of accessibility and choice. We need a new Mental Health Bill. We need money to reach the front line and we need a genuine choice for patients. But above all, we need the political will to ensure that mental health is not the "Cinderella" service.


Oliver Heald is the Conservative MP for North East Hertfordshire and Shadow Health Spokesman
 
pH7
Also in this issue:
01. About Lilly

Lilly UK

02. Introductin to Special Focus

pH7 - Special Focus on Schizophrenia

03. Britain: the stressed man of Europe?

Dr Ian Gibson MP analyses theresults of an exclusive pH7 / Harris Poll of Members of Parliament on mental health

04. The great leap forward

The inclusion of mental health in the NHS Plan is a fantastic step forward which will revolutionise how services are delivered, says Louis Appleby

05. Out of sight, out of mind

No-one paid attention to Christopher Clunis until he murdered Jayne Zito's husband. Sally Dawson reports

06. The Cinderella Service

The government is simply failing to deliver on its mental health promises, says Oliver Heald MP, and sufferers remain forgotten

07. Eyes wide shut

When it comes to mental health, people still turn their heads away, says Sandra Gidley MP

08. Rhetoric and reality

People need recognition of their individuality not one-for-all placements, writes Marjorie Wallace

09. Shrink-wrapped services

The image of psychiatry is all too often one of protocol bound inflexibility, writes Dr Martin Deahl

10. Severe mental illness: time for a rethink

We need to challenge ourselves and our approaches if we are to overcome stigma and break down barriers so people can access the best treatment available, writes Cliff Prior

11. Medication: a question of choice?

For Tim Newey, being prescribed the right type of medication was the equivalent of a rope being thrown to him in a 'very dark place'. So, he writes, when it comes to quality of care for mental health patients, you get what you pay for

12. Ending the stigma

If there was no shame attached to a visit to a psychiatrist then people would be more likely to seek help when they need it, writes Lynne Jones MP

13. Re-engaging the world

Sally Dawson reviews A Beautiful Mind

14. Postcards from the front line

Sally Dawson reports how Dr David Pelta and his team have transformed the delivery of community-based mental health services

15. Financing new drugs in the NHS

Dr Roger Bullock shares his experience of the challenge of getting appropriate care to patients

16. Labour mental health policy: coercive or creative?

So often for the mentally ill, second best - it seems - is good enough, says Professor Ray Rowden