Seeking substance »

Cameron's coming of age

25/09/08 | by Michael Gove [mail] | Categories: Conservative, Conservative conference

Michael Gove
Michael Gove analyses the startling turnaround in political fortunes of Gordon Brown and David Cameron which has taken place over the past 12 months, and gives a flavour of Conservative strategy for the year ahead.

The reversal of fortunes since last September has been so dramatic, and profound, that any further comment might seem superfluous. But reflecting on the past 12 months, and the next, certain points do seem worth making.

1. The huge decline in Gordon Brown's position, and the strength of David Cameron's, is I believe an honest reflection of their different capabilities but it is also a reminder of the volatility of politics and the fatal danger of taking the public for granted. That is why, as Labour turns in on itself and conducts its internal power struggle, David is stepping up the pace of Tory policy development and working harder than ever to offer strong alternative leadership. Expect to see more initiatives like David's trip to Georgia and his economic recovery plan as the party goes into ever greater detail about its plans to improve our country's position.

2. The belief that the Government has lost ground because of bad luck or Gordon Brown's neglect of basic PR is quite wrong - and reflects a misreading of how team Brown works. Far from concentrating on long-term decision-making in the national interest and thus, rather nobly, eschewing low political manouevring, the Prime Minister and his closest allies have failed because they concentrated so much on PR and stunts and so little on policy. From their sly briefing on casinos and 24-hour drinking (designed to please social conservatives in the media) to their botched abolition of the 10p tax rate (designed to give the impression of tax-cutting overall) to their depiction of the Tory candidate in Crewe as a top-hatted toff, the Labour machine has been driven by short-term media imperatives, and starved of any real policy fuel.

When policy has been announced it has either been a botched or lame attempt to borrow from the Tories (Darling stealing ineptly from Osborne over inheritance tax, Purnell purloining Grayling's ideas on welfare reform) or a tacking to the left in order to create "dividing lines" between the Government on one side and both Blairites and Conservatives on the other (less autonomy for academies, putting A-levels on death row, attacking faith schools).

What the government has lacked - and what has therefore driven it down in the polls - is any sense of clear philosophical direction or any real policy substance. Gordon Brown's comments about shallow salesman and lack of substance are a classic case of "projection" - accusing others of behaviour you know you're guilt of yourself.

3. The belief that the Tory recovery has been driven by smart PR and a slim policy portfolio (inheritance tax and that's about it...) is equally erroneous.

At the beginning of his leadership campaign in 2005 David Cameron chose the education portfolio as his platform, made strengthening the family a policy priority, talked of the need to heal our fractured society, argued that quality of life issues were hugely important and underlined that modernisation would have to be much more ambitious than most in the party were yet ready to concede.

Three years on what is remarkable is how consistent to those principles his leadership has been. The reforms to education and welfare he's announced, the policies he's developed on the family and relationships, the way in which he's woven a sophisticated yet tough approach on crime-fighting into a broader analysis of what's wrong with modern Britain, and the hard detail on decentralised energy, feed-in tariffs and environmental protection all reflect clear and deep policy thinking which has guided action throughout this Parliament

Of course, the issues which David has talked about, and developed policy on, have broadened since the start of his leadership challenge as we've moved closer to the general election but what is consistently under-appreciated is the continuity of analysis, outlook and deep policy thinking throughout his leadership.

4. Tory economic policy has been vindicated, not undermined, by events. The decision not to offer either big up-front tax cuts early in this Parliament, or make extravagant spending pledges, has been justified by events. Given the deterioration in public finances under Brown anything else would have been imprudent.

The decision to offer a specific and costed promise on inheritance tax was justified by events. It spoke to popular concern, reflected our core commitment to rewarding aspiration and supporting families, it was properly costed and Labour's response only left the Government looking weaker.

The criticism of the Government's handling of Northern Rock was justified by events. Critics argued that David Cameron and George Osborne went over the top. Given how disastrous things look now they appear to have been prudently prescient.
The criticism of Darling's handling of tax policy overall has been justified by events. Every major decision taken on his watch is now either under review or has been found grievously wanting.

In short, the belief that George Osborne would better manage the economy that Alistair Darling is not primarily a matter of global events humbling the Chancellor, it reflects the fact that on all the major calls the Shadow Chancellor was right and the current Chancellor (at time of writing) was wrong.

5. The coming year will be dominated by foreign events - in this arena Cameron now comprehensively outclasses Brown.
Whether its the response to events in Georgia, instinctive rapport with US Presidential candidates, or an understanding of our forces' position in Iraq and Afghanistan, David Cameron has proven in the last 12 months that he has a much surer touch on the world stage than Gordon Brown.

As the world becomes a more dangerous place then David Cameron seems both more sensitive to how global currents are moving and more skilled in navigating them.

It would be dangerous to go much further into the future at this stage. But there is one thing which I hope the 5 points I have made does underline - and one thing which hasn't changed in the last 12 months - people are still underestimating David Cameron.

Michael Gove MP is shadow children, schools and families secretary and an associate editor of the House Magazine

This is a version of an article that first appeared in the Conservative conference edition of the House Magazine

Bookmark and Share

Trackback address for this post

Trackback URL (right click and copy shortcut/link location)

No comments yet

Leave a comment


Your email address will not be revealed on this site.

Your URL will be displayed.
(Line breaks become
)

(Name, email & website)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will not be revealed.)
October 2008
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
 << <   > >>
    1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31    

Search

XML Feeds

About MP blogs

ePolitix.com publishes articles written by MPs and peers, designed to encourage public participation in policy debates. Please add your comments to the articles available here.

Please read our guidelines on acceptable posts and comments.

MP Services

ePolitix.com provides a range of bespoke communications services for MPs and their staff, including monitoring mentions in Parliament and press releases, legislative briefings, online consultations and website hosting.

ePolitix.com
Dods Websites
Advertise

Spread your message to an audience that counts, with options available for The House Magazine , the Parliamentary Monitor , the Regional Monitor and Blue Skies.