Westminster Scotland Wales London Northern Ireland European Union Local
ePolitix.com

 
[ Advanced Search ]

Login | Contact | Terms | Accessibility

PM 'reflects' on Butler report
Number 10

Number 10 has said the prime minister will reflect on the conclusions of the Butler report.

Tony Blair's official spokesman confirmed that lessons would be learned from Lord Butler's criticism of the way intelligence on Iraqi weapons of mass destruction was handled.

"Obviously there are implications within the Butler report which we will have to reflect on, and the wider system will have to reflect on," said the spokesman.

"We will do so but do so in a considered way rather than in any knee-jerk way."

Lord Butler had also criticised the prime minister's informal style of government and the lack of Cabinet involvement in the decision to go to war.

But Number 10 insisted that "Cabinet government is alive and well" - even though senior ministers did not discuss the Butler report when they met on Thursday.

"There have been detailed discussions on all the domestic subjects such as departmental five-year plans," added the spokesman.

Speaking earlier, deputy prime minister John Prescott also defended the Cabinet's role in Blair's administration.

"I can tell you, as one of those who participated in the Cabinet discussion, we did back the judgment of Tony Blair," he told the BBC's Today programme.

"We did receive the information and judgments from our colleagues and in some cases we had papers to discuss, and in all these areas we made a collective decision.

"This wasn't Tony Blair on his own. It was a collective responsibility of the Cabinet and we did do that."

Mistakes made

Lord Butler listed a series of intelligence and presentational failings that led to the case for war being put in stronger terms than it should have been.

But the prime minister's official spokesman said the Butler inquiry was the fourth review to find no evidence of bad faith in the presentation of official intelligence.

And Number 10 also brushed aside Thursday's media headlines that summed up the official response as being "no one's to blame" for the failings.

"Nobody takes more seriously than the prime minister the loss of life - whether it is military life or civilian life," said the spokesman.

"Equally, the prime minister continues to believe that the central reasons for going to war remain as valid today as they were then."

He added: "We have made no attempt to minimise the fact that mistakes were made and to accept responsibility for the mistakes that were made.

"Bad faith has not been found in any of the four inquiries which have been carried out into this subject.

"In government there's a very important distinction between making mistakes in good faith and in bad faith. That's an important distinction."

Question mark

As the dust began to settle on the Butler report, the Conservatives said questions still remained of  the prime minister's judgment.

"This does raise a very serious question about the credibility of the prime minister," Michael Ancram told the Today programme.

The shadow foreign secretary said there was a "total discrepancy between what was said by the intelligence community in relation to their own intelligence and what the prime minister told us".

And Liberal Democrat leader Charles Kennedy said the report had failed to look at some of the wider questions on the decision to go to war.

"There is not the identification of the political operators involved, not just the elected politicians but unelected political players - the Alastair Campbells of this world, the Jonathan Powells of this world in and around Number 10 Downing Street in hugely important positions," he said.

Published: Thu, 15 Jul 2004 12:20:13 GMT+01