The Home Affairs committee published its fifth report on anti-social behaviour on April 5 2005 and focused on three manifestations of anti-social behaviour: (i) that perpetrated by young people, (ii) neighbour nuisance and (iii) alcohol-related disorder.
As a result of its inquiry, the committee concluded that the extent of anti-social behaviour had not been exaggerated by the government or the media.
The committee also argued that the government’s strategy to deal with anti-social behaviour was “not overwhelmingly punitive towards children.”
Amongst the recommendations in the report it was suggested that parenting orders should be used more frequently. The committee also argued that in the case of children under the age of 18, the law should be amended so that magistrates have a greater discretion to set the duration of an Anti-Social Behaviour Order (ASBO) as it may be inappropriate for it to last for a minimum of two years.
In response to the effect of the new licensing laws on anti-social behaviour, the committee concluded there was no certain evidence to suggest the problem would be improved or worsened.
To read the committee report in full please click here.
Summary of responses:
British Property Federation
-
Believes social landlords are better equipped to deal with anti-social tenants since they have access to social workers and the police.
-
Private landlords are less well-equipped so it makes little sense to evict anti-social tenants from social landlords to the private sector.
-
The government needs to introduce a comprehensive strategy to deal with anti-social behaviour in the private sector.
Disability Rights Commission
-
Argues the disproportionate rates of harassment, bullying, rejection and fear experienced by disabled people of all ages must be systematically addressed.
-
Welcomes the government’s respect agenda but urges it must have as its aim the creation of strong, cohesive, tolerant and inclusive communities.
-
Subsequent ‘naming and shaming’ of people by the police or housing officer, risks further excluding and stigmatising individuals.
-
Clear lines of accountability along with adequate and effective safeguards must be put in place.
-
Would like to see improved systems for monitoring, recording and handling incidences of hate crime and harassment against disabled people.
